causal

Emergence Is a Restatement of Magic

Consciousness is not like the emergent motion of a car, because with a car you can draw a strict material correlation between the movement of all the parts and the larger motion, whereas no such correlation exists for consciousness; therefore appeals to emergence to explain consciousness are really appeals to magic.

causalpending

Speaker

Ross Douthat

Evidence Quote

“When people talk about emergence to me, they're still talking about magic.”

Source

Rational and Religious (with Ross Douthat)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:12 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...