causal
Identifiability Would Close the Pond-Charity Gap
If giving money to charity could guarantee saving a specific identifiable person—whose name, clothes, and background we knew, with the same certainty as saving the pond child—the intuitive moral gap between the two would dissipate, and we would regard the non-giver as psychopathic; the gap exists only because of non-identifiability, diffusion of responsibility, and uncertainty.
causalpending
Speaker
David EdmondsEvidence Quote
“if the world was such that we could guarantee our actions had this much good on the other side of the world then i think we would begin to see the person who failed to help as psychopathic in the same way as the person we would regard as psychopathic if they ignored the child in the shallow pond”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:20 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...