normative

Anecdotes Wrongly Substituting for Aggregate Evidence

Concrete storytelling legitimately gets a bad rap when it is used to serve roles that should be served by general explanation—such as basing public policy on an anecdote rather than data and large-scale generalizations—since anecdotes and good stories are persuasive and can be mistaken for strong evidence; the remedy is to legitimize valuable roles for stories without mistaking them for aggregate evidence.

normativepending

Speaker

Tania Lombrozo

Evidence Quote

“In the context of persuasion, anecdotes and good stories are persuasive... those might be cases where they legitimately get a bad rap in so far as they are being mistaken for strong evidence... maybe what we need to do is legitimize valuable roles for stories... as long as we don't mistake it for playing the role of giving us the abstract generalization.”

Source

223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...