factual

All Bold Macro Theories Get Rejected By Data

Every macroeconomic theory that makes bold strong predictions has cases where those predictions failed to pan out; if subjected to rigorous statistical testing—even generously treating the theory as the null hypothesis—all of them would be rejected, which is why macroeconomists have retreated to using theories as thought experiments that merely 'organize our thinking' by mapping assumptions to conclusions.

factualpending

Speaker

Noah Smith

Evidence Quote

“macroeconomists have retreated mostly to using these things as thought experiments, or the sort of weasely phrase that people will use is, 'Ah--they organize our thinking.' They are a map between the assumptions and conclusions”

Source

Noah Smith on Whether Economics is a Science— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...