causal

No separate language module; spoken-language circuit does grammar

Jarvis accepts a genetic predisposition (language instinct) to learn to imitate sounds but disagrees with Chomsky's separate language module: there is no good evidence for it, and the brain pathway controlling grammar and syntax is the spoken-language motor learning pathway itself, fed by the pre-existing auditory pathway (including Wernicke's area) common to many vertebrates—which is why dogs can understand rudimentary human speech.

causalpending

Speaker

Erich Jarvis

Evidence Quote

“I don't think there's good evidence for a separate language module. I think the brain pathway that's actually controlling the grammar, the syntax... is the spoken language pathway itself”

Source

127 | Erich Jarvis on Language, Birds, and People— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...