causal
No separate language module; spoken-language circuit does grammar
Jarvis accepts a genetic predisposition (language instinct) to learn to imitate sounds but disagrees with Chomsky's separate language module: there is no good evidence for it, and the brain pathway controlling grammar and syntax is the spoken-language motor learning pathway itself, fed by the pre-existing auditory pathway (including Wernicke's area) common to many vertebrates—which is why dogs can understand rudimentary human speech.
causalpending
Speaker
Erich JarvisEvidence Quote
“I don't think there's good evidence for a separate language module. I think the brain pathway that's actually controlling the grammar, the syntax... is the spoken language pathway itself”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:44 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...