causal
Pragmatist usefulness has little to do with truth
The objection to the pragmatist theory is that usefulness has almost nothing to do with truth: an experimental-validation reading misses candidates for truth that make no predictions (e.g., properties of God), and because usefulness is relative to a goal, one can have useful lies and can worryingly make things true or false by varying the goal parameter—which is irrelevant to what we wanted truth to be (univalent).
causalpending
Speaker
Liam Kofi BrightEvidence Quote
“now it looks like I can worryingly make things true or false by varying that third parameter, and that just seems irrelevant. It wasn't like what we were initially trying to do with truth.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...