normative
Fantasy Intellectual Teams reward reasoned discourse
By scoring public intellectuals on categories like thinking in bets, offering caveats, showing an open mind, steelmanning opponents, and honestly evaluating research, a 'Fantasy Intellectual Teams' system could shift status away from Twitter Likes and partisan slams toward rational discourse—raising the status of careful thinkers like Scott Alexander and Emily Oster and lowering that of partisan hacks.
normativepending
Speaker
Arnold KlingEvidence Quote
“if the public were paying attention to these points, they would be looking at more rational discourse, less tribal discourse. And the result would be to raise the status of the Scott Alexanders and Emily Osters, and lower the status of the, sort of, partisan hacks.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:57 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...