normative
Victim Self-Identification Test for Moral Orders
To distinguish legitimate from illegitimate emergent moral orders without full cultural relativism, examine whether the apparent victims themselves feel victimized—slaves fled and resisted, so slavery is condemnable, whereas if veiling women genuinely endorse their practices and can articulate non-crazy justifications, multiple emergent moral orders may be legitimate (subject to caveats about false consciousness).
normativepending
Speaker
Jonathan HaidtEvidence Quote
“if they themselves think they are victims, that's enough of a reason for us to condemn it... there could be multiple emergent moral orders in which even the people that we think are victims endorse it”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:45 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...