normative

Peer review is worse than nothing

A system that claims to do something but doesn't actually do it is worse than nothing because it gains unwarranted trust and leaves people worse off—analogous to an FDA that only sniffs beef—and combined with its obvious costs in money and time against an unclear benefit, peer review is worse than having no such system.

normativepending

Speaker

Adam Mastroianni

Evidence Quote

“what's really bad is to think that a system is trustworthy when it isn't”

Source

Adam Mastroianni on Peer Review and the Academic Kitchen— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:08:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...