normative

Optimistic On Agency, Pessimistic On Top-Down Design

The right orientation is optimism about individual human agency, the width of the right tail, and the transmissibility of new knowledge, combined with pessimism about the ability of groups of humans to engage in effective ex ante top-down design—echoing Seeing Like a State's critique of monoculture—which is why we need mechanisms to break out of the monoculture.

normativepending

Speaker

Patrick Collison

Evidence Quote

“I'm very optimistic about sort of individual human agency; and I'm very optimistic about sort of the width of the right tail. And I'm very optimistic about the sort of transmissibility of new knowledge. And I'm sort of pessimistic about the ability of groups of humans to engage in effective, ex ante, top-down design.”

Source

Patrick Collison on Innovation and Scientific Progress— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:12 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...