factual

War Requires Surplus And Overkill

War always requires surplus because you don't know how it will run; nuclear 'overkill' was rational because two equally balanced forces need more weapons than minimally necessary to assure a surviving second-strike capability, which deters a first strike—so Israel should likewise maintain military overkill and never economize when survival is at stake.

factualpending

Speaker

Mark Helprin

Evidence Quote

“War requires surplus...That's why we had overkill, to assure the possibility of a second strike. Which would deter a first strike.”

Source

Reading, Writing, and Fighting (with Mark Helprin)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:25 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...