factual

Subjective Comparison More Objective Than Rubrics

Paradoxically, having teachers make open-ended comparative judgments of student writing with no rubric produces very high agreement (objectivity), while marking the same essays with a detailed rubric and tick-lists produces low agreement (subjectivity), because comparative judgment captures tacit knowledge of quality that prose rubrics fail to specify.

factualpending

Speaker

Daisy Christodoulou

Evidence Quote

“what feels like an incredibly subjective method of assessment, the data shows it is actually really quite objective. And, the flip side is true: That when you have this very objective measure... when you crunch the numbers, people do not agree at all... so it's actually very subjective.”

Source

Coase, the Rules of the Game, and the Costs of Perfection (with Daisy Christodoulou)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:59 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...