normative
Choice is the best human-level theory of people
Describing human beings as agents who make choices is justified because it is the best theory we have of people at the human level of description, and it is in fact everyone's working theory; even those who deny free will cannot actually live or talk as if people do not make choices, illustrated by the Alice and Bob navigation example where attributing a choice is the only sane description.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“you can't live in the world, because it's not a good description of the world at the human level to act as if human beings don't make choices... that's the best theory we have of people, and it literally is everyone's theory. There's no one who doesn't have that theory, because it works, it's true.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...