factual

Stone Soup problem of Many-Worlds assumptions

The Many-Worlds approach falls prey to what Barandes calls the Stone Soup problem: although advertised as axiomatically simple (just quantum state plus Schrodinger evolution), deriving the Born rule actually requires stacking many hard-to-justify speculative metaphysical hypotheses—richness axioms, rationality axioms, assumptions about valuing uncountable future copies of oneself, orthogonality of distinct possibilities—each of which lowers one's Bayesian credence in the theory.

factualpending

Speaker

Jacob Barandes

Evidence Quote

“you have to stack so many of these, I call them speculative metaphysical hypotheses, SMHs, on top of each other, and each one reduces my Bayesian credence”

Source

323 | Jacob Barandes on Indivisible Stochastic Quantum Mechanics— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...