normative
No Free Will Doesn't Abolish Punishment
Accepting that free will is an illusion does not entail that no one should be punished; like removing a broken machine from a factory, restraint and deterrence remain justified to protect the innocent — what is removed is the moral case for retribution and vengeance, not for protection.
normativepending
Speaker
Ricky GervaisEvidence Quote
“we got to still protect the innocent... retribution doesn't or the vengeance part of it doesn't morally”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:52:11 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...