normative
Objective Valuation Is Not Mainly Paternalistic
The law's use of objective rather than purely subjective valuation, though it sounds paternalistic, is actually unavoidable in most moral judgments—as shown by self-defense law, where we would not let someone use deadly force to defend a mere trinket simply because they value it more than their body; once interests can diverge from preferences, respecting all bargains becomes problematic.
normativepending
Speaker
Leo KatzEvidence Quote
“It still is just a trinket, and you can't use deadly force to defend a trinket.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:23 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...