factual

Rebuttal to Penrose on Human Creativity

Penrose's argument (updating Lucas) that human creativity can never be simulated by a machine fails because it requires the further unjustified step that humans are 'perfect mathematicians' who can infallibly see the consistency of formal systems; once you grant a machine the same liberties humans have — to learn from experience, make mistakes, and say 'I don't know' — there is nothing math or logic can say against a machine doing as well as or better than a human.

factualpending

Speaker

Scott Aaronson

Evidence Quote

“as soon as you grant a machine the same liberty that it can try to learn from experience, it can make mistakes sometimes, it can sometimes just give up and say, "I don't know," then there is no longer anything that math or logic can say against the machine doing just as well as a human does, or better than a human does”

Source

99 | Scott Aaronson on Complexity, Computation, and Quantum Gravity— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:25 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...