normative

Critical Level View Avoids the Repugnant Conclusion

Taking a compromise across views of population ethics yields a critical level view: above the zero level (indifference between existing and never having existed) there is a higher critical threshold, and only bringing into existence a life above that threshold counts as good, so adding barely-worth-living lives is not good and may be bad—this rejects unrestricted dominance addition and avoids the repugnant conclusion.

normativepending

Speaker

William MacAskill

Evidence Quote

“what I think we ultimately want to do is take a compromise between different moral world views... what that ends up giving you, if you really reason it through, is what's called a critical level view.”

Source

207 | William MacAskill on Maximizing Good in the Present and Future— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...