causal
Qualia Are By-Products of High Intelligence
The claim that current biology and natural selection cannot explain qualia (the texture of daily life, aesthetic and moral sense, creative imagination) is not a strong argument, because once a brain evolves sufficient intelligence—which has clear selective value (you can outsmart a sabre-tooth tiger even if you can't outrun it)—those experiences emerge as by-products that require no direct selective mechanism, just as a hammer designed for nails can also serve as a paperweight.
causalpending
Speaker
Alan LightmanEvidence Quote
“I think that some of our aesthetic sense, our moral sense, our creative imagination is a by-product of qualities that do have selective value”
Source
Alan Lightman on Science, Spirituality, and Searching for Stars on an Island in Maine— EconTalkCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:25:04 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...