causal

Holding responsible derives from exhortation

Once commitment becomes a practice, related practices of exhortation (urging someone in advance to keep a commitment) and holding responsible emerge; when someone fails, rather than abandoning them, one says 'you could have done it' — reactively adopting the exhortation stance and still treating the person as exhortable, which amounts to holding them responsible.

causalpending

Speaker

Philip Pettit

Evidence Quote

“reactively adopting that stance, treating you still as exhortable, saying you could have done it, Sean, I'm not giving up on you. That that actually amounts to holding you responsible.”

Source

322 | Philip Pettit on Language, Agency, Politics, and Freedom— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:45 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...