causal
AI Is an Assistant, Not a Substitute for Judgment
Advanced AI provides good algorithms that can assist economic decision-making but cannot substitute for human desire, imagination, and interpretive judgment; because Polanyi (via Gödel's incompleteness and the syntax-versus-semantics distinction) showed a machine can never be a mind, and market prices require interpretation of meaning—agents must read a price signal, decide whether to use less, substitute, or innovate, and be tested against the market—AI is like Deep Blue at chess but the real economy resembles the on-the-fly creativity of Larry Bird or Federer.
causalpending
Speaker
Peter BoettkeEvidence Quote
“market economies are about, as you've pointed out, people reading the price signal. They have to understand the meaning that's involved in that... rather than testing the computer--again, a Deep Blue against Kasparov--we should test the computer against Ronaldo playing soccer or Federer playing tennis... Larry Bird is an act of creativity the entire time he's playing... AI is a good assistant... but it doesn't substitute for our ingenuity, cleverness, and creativity.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:12:04 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...