causal

Hong Kong Versus Guangzhou As Natural Experiment

British imperialism worked far better in Hong Kong than in most of the rest of the world, and the comparison with nearby Guangzhou functions as close to a natural experiment: until very recently Hong Kong was much richer than Guangzhou, and without the British, Hong Kong's living standards would reasonably have resembled the rest of Southern China rather than being an extreme outlier, suggesting British rule drove its prosperity.

causalpending

Speaker

Tyler Cowen

Evidence Quote

“You can look at Guangzhou — it’s a fairly close comparator. Until very recently, Hong Kong was much, much richer than Guangzhou. Without the British, it would be reasonable to assume living standards in Hong Kong would’ve been about those of the rest of Southern China, right?... Isn’t that close to a natural experiment?”

Source

Rebecca F. Kuang— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:20:00 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...