factual
Existence and non-existence may be incomparable
It may be a mistake to treat being brought into existence as a benefit because comparing existence to non-existence is conceptually strange—the better-than relation holds between beings that exist—so the procreative asymmetry (it's bad to create miserable lives but not obviously good to create happy ones) is better explained by existence and non-existence not standing in the right comparative relation, like saying the Eiffel Tower is taller than the number three.
factualpending
Speaker
Michael PlantEvidence Quote
“you need things to stand in the right kind of relation to be comparable... the Eiffel tower is taller than the number three you might say well what do I mean”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:01 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...