causal
Moral convergence weakly favors realism at most
Two predictions are sometimes attributed to moral realism: that diverse minds converge on the right morality, and that society becomes more moral over time. But moral anti-realism comfortably explains observed convergence (e.g., Aristotle and us both endorsing the march of history) through sufficiently similar agents endorsing sufficiently similar reflective processes that history in fact instantiated, so observed moral progress is at most a very weak update toward realism.
causalpending
Speaker
Joe CarlsmithEvidence Quote
“there's a sense in which maybe that prediction is more likely for realism than anti-realism, but it doesn't move me very much.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:37:01 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...