factual

Identical Data Produced Contradictory Social Science Results

In the 'Universe of Uncertainty' study, 76 non-communicating research teams given identical data on whether immigration affects support for the social safety net produced scattered results—about half found no effect, a quarter found a statistically significant positive effect, and a quarter found a statistically significant negative effect—revealing that even with controlled data and responsible methodologies, social research yields scattershot conclusions that publication bias then cements into 'settled' policy-shaping wisdom.

factualpending

Speaker

Brian Klaas

Evidence Quote

“even when you control the data, even when you try to plot the methodological choices... you get a scattershot result.”

Source

If Life Is Random, Is It Meaningless? (with Brian Klaas)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...