normative
Small Probability Large Outcome Calculus Resisted
Even granting expected-utility maximization, people will not roll a two-million-sided die and decline to save two certain lives for a one-in-two-million chance of saving two billion, because as probabilities shrink and numbers grow the calculus, though favorable on paper by orders of magnitude, breaks our ethical intuitions—and in practice tiny probabilities are so weakly evidenced that even moderate self-serving or ideological biases can flip the calculation, giving unlimited license to rationalize doing whatever one secretly wants.
normativepending
Speaker
Nick BostromEvidence Quote
“with with really really small probabilities like the evidence is very weak and and therefore even like a moderately strong bias in one way or another could easily overwhelm them”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:59:17 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...