causal

Language is a gift from public to private cognition

While consciousness itself may not depend on the external/social world, many cognitive capacities do: the internalization of external cognitive tools—language above all, as in Vygotsky's idea of inner speech—is a 'gift from the public to the private' that makes individual minds more powerful but could never have existed without a social setting; the octopus shows you can be a solitary animal with a messed-up self and still be conscious, so social rebuilding of the mind matters for human consciousness specifically rather than consciousness in general.

causalpending

Speaker

Peter Godfrey-Smith

Evidence Quote

“a kind of gift from the public to the private”

Source

249 | Peter Godfrey-Smith on Sentience and Octopus Minds— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...