factual

Bostrom simulation argument is dubious

The Nick Bostrom simulation argument—that advanced civilizations will run countless detailed neuron-level simulations of self-aware historical beings, so we are probably one such simulated being—is profoundly suspect because faithfully simulating even a bacterium will likely prove impossible within the universe's computational resources, the only way to truly simulate a bacterium being to build a physical system isomorphic to one (i.e. an actual bacterium), which yields nothing for free; a separate and harder-to-dismiss line of thought notes that the fundamental constituents of reality (quantum fields, wave functions) are circularly defined and feel informational rather than tangible, which can suggest the universe is an informational entity, but inferring from that to a literal simulation is rank speculation.

factualpending

Speaker

Anthony Aguirre

Evidence Quote

“the only way to really simulate a bacterium will be to create a physical system that is like isomorphic to a bacterium... So this will just not be an exciting thing to do.”

Source

51 | Anthony Aguirre on Cosmology, Zen, Entropy, and Information— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:03 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...