factual
Aggregative Ethics Has No Agreed Solution
Once ethics moves to aggregates—weighing the value of rational persons against sentient non-persons and summing across them—no one knows what to do, because parsing value in nature rests on insanely controversial and unresolved questions, so whether human extinction would be a boon or loss for sentient life overall is genuinely indeterminate.
factualpending
Speaker
Rachell PowellEvidence Quote
“how we put together the value of say, rational persons against sentient non-persons and then add it all up and figure out some kind of... Is it... And there is no agreement on this. Once you get to aggregates and ethics, no one knows what to do.”
Source
342 | Rachell Powell on Evolutionary Convergence, Morality, and Mind— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:29:32 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...