causal

First-Person Reports Deserve Deep Skepticism

First-person reports that a drug 'worked for me' should be approached with huge cautionary skepticism for three reasons that work together: the natural course of disease (symptoms fluctuate or naturally decline, and people seek treatment at their worst, so regression to the mean alone produces apparent improvement), the placebo effect, and confirmation bias.

causalpending

Speaker

Jacob Stegenga

Evidence Quote

“if you seek treatment when your symptoms are especially bad, then merely the passage of time alone entails that your symptoms will get better in the future... So these three problems together--the natural course of diseases, the placebo effect, and confirmation bias--entail that we should treat first-person reports regarding the effects of interventions with a huge amount of skepticism.”

Source

Jacob Stegenga on Medical Nihilism— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:09:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...