normative

Thin Duty To Avoid Gratuitous Suffering Commands Consensus

A deliberately thin ethical principle — the duty to avoid causing gratuitous suffering (suffering without any adequate reason), whether through intent, recklessness, or negligence — can command genuine overlapping consensus across any reasonable ethical starting point, precisely because it is so weak, and can therefore ground public policy at the edge of sentience even though many will hold stronger duties privately.

normativepending

Speaker

Jonathan Birch

Evidence Quote

“I think that principle is so weak in a way, it's so thin, the duty to avoid causing gratuitous suffering, where gratuitous implies the absence of any adequate reason for what you're doing. I think because it is so deliberately thin, it then can command genuine consensus.”

Source

292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:27:32 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...