The Garland Test from Ex Machina—where Ava the robot is known to be a robot from the start and the test is whether the observer still attributes consciousness despite this knowledge—is superior to the Turing Test because it tests for consciousness directly rather than intelligence, and it aligns with Wittgenstein's insight that consciousness attribution is conventional rather than metaphysical.

causalpending

Speaker

Murray Shanahan

Evidence Quote

“the point is to show you she's a robot, right? So you straight away you know there it's not hidden from you... It's testing for consciousness... this is very Wikensteinian.”

Source

Human vs. Machine Consciousness | Imperial’s Murray Shanahan— Johnathan Bi
Created: 8/11/2026, 5:29:41 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...