factual

Pre-publication peer review lacks supporting evidence

Bright and Remco Heesen argue that most of the things pre-publication peer review is supposed to do—e.g., sorting good ideas from bad or true claims from false—have either no evidence that it succeeds or some evidence that it fails; it is labor-intensive, time-consuming, and lucrative for publishers, yet the claim that a couple of reviewers' judgments reliably select for quality is not borne out, with a small-c conservative bias against daring work.

factualpending

Speaker

Liam Kofi Bright

Evidence Quote

“most of the things which pre-publication peer review is meant to do for us, there's either no evidence that it does it or some evidence that it fails to do it.”

Source

95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...