normative
Restorative justice has intrinsic value beyond consequences
Restorative justice can be defended on purely consequentialist grounds, but it also has separate intrinsic value as the most just outcome; even in a case where it produced a slightly less-than-optimal result for society at large, Summers would still endorse it for justice reasons alone, provided the consequentialist price is not too high—marking the point where his meta-ethics diverge from Harris's.
normativepending
Speaker
Tamler SummersEvidence Quote
“i would still endorse the restorative approach even though it led to a less optimal outcome... i think that that has kind of intrinsic value over and above whatever consequences it has”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:10:38 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...