causal

Peer Review Versus Reality Feedback

Fields where feedback comes from peer review rather than from reality become closed, self-validating systems — a carpenter gets feedback from clients, but a macroeconomist only gets feedback from another macroeconomist like Paul Krugman, allowing such fields to give themselves Nobels while disconnected from reality.

causalpending

Speaker

Nassim Nicholas Taleb And Bryan Caplan

Evidence Quote

“I put in Skin in the Game what happens to fields where the feedback is peer reviewed, not feedback coming from reality.”

Source

Nassim Nicholas Taleb And Bryan Caplan— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:18:56 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...