causal

Retributive Anger Is Empty Magical Thinking

The wish for payback embedded in anger (the thought that it would be right to take retaliation) is counterproductive and a form of empty magical thinking — believing that punishing an offender will restore cosmic balance — which neither assuages grief nor reduces future crime, so backward-looking retribution can never justify punishment.

causalpending

Speaker

Martha Nussbaum

Evidence Quote

“people think oh my child has been killed well if i make sure that this offender gets the death penalty then that will pay back and then things will be even in the cosmos the cosmic balance will be struck and it doesn't do anything”

Source

309 - Vulnerability Politics And Moral Worth— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:59:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...