normative

Gilded Age comparison misuses market income

Claiming the US has returned to a 1920s 'Gilded Era' because the top 1% market-income share is comparable ignores that there was no Social Security system then; today's elderly with little market income are sustained by transfers, so comparing only market income across these eras completely misuses the data to imply equivalent well-being inequality.

normativepending

Speaker

Richard Burkhauser

Evidence Quote

“to make comparisons with what's been going on with market income and imply something about the economic wellbeing of people in the United States, is to completely misuse Piketty and Saez's numbers.”

Source

Richard Burkhauser on the Middle Class— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:11 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...