causal
Sand pile criticality was an artifact of ignoring inertia
The famous claim that sand piles self-organize to criticality without tuning was misleading: Sid Nagel's experiments showed real sand piles are not scale-invariant because the models had neglected grain inertia, and ignoring inertia is equivalent to setting it to zero, which is equivalent to tuning the system to a critical point—so apparent self-organized criticality can be an artifact of modeling simplifications.
causalpending
Speaker
Nigel GoldenfeldEvidence Quote
“Ignoring something is the same as setting it equal to zero. And setting it equal to zero is the same as tuning it.”
Source
163 | Nigel Goldenfeld on Phase Transitions, Criticality, and Biology— Sean Carroll's MindscapeCreated: 6/13/2026, 12:25:50 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...