normative

Fanatical longtermism deflated by uncertainty

Fanatical longtermism—where tiny probabilities of vast future payoffs swamp present concerns—can be deflated on several grounds: it is peculiar to upend your priorities for outcomes you are not even confident have value; larger claimed payoffs (Pascal's mugging) should lower your assigned probability; and we have little evidence humans can reliably influence the long-term future in a large, positive direction, so discounting for uncertainty shrinks the supposedly near-infinite expected values.

normativepending

Speaker

Michael Plant

Evidence Quote

“do we really have any evidence from the past that people have been able to influence the long term... it seems like we should really not have much confidence that we can influence the long term future”

Source

446 - How To Do The Most Good— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...