factual

Smith Torn on Whether Conditions Deform Capabilities

Adam Smith was internally torn: in The Wealth of Nations he clearly held that bad worldly conditions deform human capabilities (children doing monotonous work all day become deformed, unlike educated Scottish children), but in the Stoic-influenced Theory of Moral Sentiments he waffled, admiring how slaves and Native Americans endured mutilation and torture without complaint — a macho stoicism inherited from Seneca that loosened his attention to how people should actually live.

factualpending

Speaker

Martha Nussbaum

Evidence Quote

“it's this kind of macho stoicism that he gets, I'm afraid, from Seneca and the people that he loved. Which kind of stops him from thinking, how should people actually live?”

Source

Martha Nussbaum on Creating Capabilities and GDP— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...