normative

We Are Not Randomly Selected Observers

Cosmological reasoning like the doomsday argument and Boltzmann-brain selection fails because we cannot validly treat ourselves as uniformly selected among all observers across spacetime; the assumption of typicality that underlies such arguments is unjustified, so we should not update our credences toward doom simply because we exist early.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“I often hear physicists reworking their ideas in order to avoid Boltzmann brain situations, but this seems to clash with another idea I've heard you express. Namely, that we can't think of ourselves as being uniformly selected among all observers.”

Source

AMA | September 2023— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:08 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...