normative

Fields create necessary membranes for diversity

Tradition and disciplinary fields are critical because they create membranes between communities that let each maintain its own standards and tastes, and those standards become resources other fields can draw on; if everything becomes interdisciplinary or post-disciplinary, you destroy the very intellectual, dispositional, and epistemic assets that serve as building blocks for new knowledge—leaving 'mush' with no structure.

normativepending

Speaker

James Evans

Evidence Quote

“You need the different communities to talk to each other, but they also need to be different communities. Otherwise they become just homogeneous.”

Source

304 | James Evans on Innovation, Consolidation, and the Science of Science— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:39 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...