normative

The 'So-Like-Us' Approach to Animal Rights Is Flawed

The 'so-like-us' approach to animal law — carving out personhood and special rights only for animals very similar to humans, such as great apes and elephants — is the wrong basis for protection because it leaves out all other suffering animals, is biologically incoherent (many animals have capacities we lack), and grounds benefits in resemblance to us rather than in who the animals themselves are.

normativepending

Speaker

Martha Nussbaum

Evidence Quote

“it just seems to me the wrong reason to give a benefit to an animal because of us because they happen to be like us”

Source

309 - Vulnerability Politics And Moral Worth— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:59:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...