factual

Body-Only Cognition Is Unstable Middle Ground

The intermediate position that the whole body counts as part of cognition but external tools do not is unstable; if you accept that using your fingers to count makes them part of the machinery of mind, you cannot consistently deny that a constantly carried pocket calculator is part of that machinery.

factualpending

Speaker

Andy Clark

Evidence Quote

“as soon as you start thinking, okay, if I'm using my fingers to help me count then my fingers somehow count as part of the machinery of mind”

Source

235 | Andy Clark on the Extended and Predictive Mind— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...