causal

Bea's Objection: Proportionate Sacrifice

The law's refusal to enforce certain bargains tracks Bea's objection in triage: she can accept sacrificing her leg so Al's two legs are treated (a justifiable, proportionate sacrifice) but not for the sake of Chloe's trivial finger—even though she gets treated in neither case—because being asked to make a significant sacrifice for a trivial competing interest is unjust, and this same objection appears across many legal contexts.

causalpending

Speaker

Leo Katz

Evidence Quote

“I can't see being asked to make that sacrifice for the sake of Chloe's finger, even if Al wants that to be the case”

Source

Leo Katz on Why the Law is So Perverse— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...