causal

Pareto Improvements Can Widen Inequality

Voluntary contracts can produce Pareto improvements—both parties gain—yet with unequal gains that widen the gap: if two people start at 10 and one moves to 12 while the other moves to 15, the summed gain is 7 but a parity-focused observer sees a new gap of 3 where there was none; progressives of the era prized parity over total gains and wrongly assumed a strong party could leave a weak party worse off, which is impossible since no one freely enters a contract that makes them worse off.

causalpending

Speaker

Richard Epstein

Evidence Quote

“So if you have two people starting at 10 and you have a contract, one could go to 12 and the other could go to 15... if you are worried about the gap you say: Oh, my God, now we have a gap of 3 whereas before we had a gap of 0.”

Source

Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:19:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...