normative
Causal Statements Require Implicit Counterfactuals
You cannot make any meaningful causal statement about history without an implicit counterfactual, so historians should make these counterfactuals explicit and interrogate them; counterfactual thinking reminds us that what happened was not bound to happen and that the future is uncertain, so the disciplined practice of assigning vague probabilities to multiple plausible futures should be central to education and to thinking about one's own life.
normativepending
Speaker
Niall FergusonEvidence Quote
“the more you think counterfactually... the more you recognize that the future is, it's not determined, it's uncertain, you and I stand before multiple plausible futures, and all we can really do at this point is attach some vague probabilities to them”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:20 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...