definition
Competitive Cognitive Artifacts Replace Ability
A second class of artifacts — calculators, cars, and machine-learning systems like AlphaGo — augment ability only while present but, unlike complementary artifacts, replace rather than rewire human capacity, so removing them leaves the person no better and probably worse (you forget long division, become unfit); AlphaGo is opaque even to its designers and replaces rather than augments our reasoning about Go, and the car is dangerous because it kills many people yet is accepted for its high utility.
definitionpending
Speaker
David KrakauerEvidence Quote
“the difference is that these what i call competitive cognitive artifacts don't so much amplify human representational ability but replace it”
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:54:31 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...