causal
Caregiving's effect is on variability not the mean
Protective caregiving works by increasing variability rather than shifting the mean—like a protected garden producing a wider variety of plants—so a loving family lets siblings develop in more divergent ways; this explains why studies find low sibling correlation (the non-shared environment) and means that the effect of nurture, being on the standard deviation rather than the mean, is invisible to standard twin studies.
causalpending
Speaker
Alison GopnikEvidence Quote
“if the effect of nurture is not on the mean but on the variation, on the standard deviation, you’re not going to see it in any straightforward way in a twin study.”
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:55:45 PM
Your notes
Loading notes...