causal

Negative heritability estimate means the study fails

Hereditarian critics argued that using later-vintage data yields a heritability confidence interval including negative values, claiming this is why it could not be published—but a negative heritability is meaningless and simply indicates the study does not work, which is a fact that should be disclosed rather than hidden; also, swapping in a different vintage of control data violates the logic of a control arm, which requires the same vintage as the treatment data.

causalpending

Speaker

David Bessis

Evidence Quote

“when you do a control group study, it's basically having a placebo arm. You're supposed to get the same vintage from the data. You cannot say the control group in 1990 was not good, but I'm going to use the one from 1995 because I like it better.”

Source

Nature, Nurture, and Identical Twins (with David Bessis)— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:15:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...